Peninsula Pizza

My family always makes the drive for here when we come up from Duncan. They are very friendly and make amazing pizza. I highly recommend the Mac daddy and the loaded baked potato pizza. They also make special pizzas for all your different dietary needs without fussing. Always friendly staff!

Some of the best pizzas I've ever had - I even come across the sea from Vancouver to eat them!This is what I look forward to when I'm on the Peninsula. Beautiful crusts - regular style but not too thick and not too heavy - perfectly cooked for some great crunch (but not so hard it scratches your mouth). Great quality toppings that are chopped big enough to stand out, and a thicker tomato sauce with some sweetness that subtly hints of cherry tomatoes on your tongue.We ordered the Super Taco pizza, which brought back the wonders of taco pizza when it first came out, back in the 80s or early 90s. Back when it was really good. Mexi-style ground beef on a light salsa base, cheddar and onions baked on their great crust and topped with lettuce, tomatoes and sour cream.We paired that with the simple Hawaiian that was a pick-up special and it did impress. The ham was better than expected and suited the sauce just right.I got one of the dips to go with that, which might have been the only drawback. The handmade dip did take great, don't get me wrong on that, but it was kind of overpriced for the portion, and I didn't think the portion was enough for the whole pizza.While the dip was a little small, the pizzas were not. The medium fed us well and the large was definitely large, even though it was the cheaper deal. The sizes and the quality of the pizzas match the prices; they totally satisfied me and even gave a good amount of leftovers.So maybe making a four hour trip like I did to get some pizza is a little much (they don't deliver to Vancouver) - but even though the pizza might get cold on that trip home, it works beautifully for locals, I think you'd probably eat it all before the ferry docks anyways, and the leftovers are still great!I'll be going back whenever I'm on the Island and I'll be working through their whole menu. Chicago style deep dish and Boss Lady Veggie in particular; but the different meat loving selections and the chicken and veggie based ones all look great - plus the ability to have them Detroit style! And now that I've heard about the calamari Kraken I'm suddenly wanting seafood on a pizza for the first time in my life (well, second, but I'll let them ask me what the other one was).

Firstly, I would like to say Pen Pizza has been my go-to Pizza place since moving to the peninsula. The staff have always been friendly and great as well as being great Pizza! However today takes the cake, I couldn't be more proud of a local company, I wasn't able to be around for the delivery, I left my card with a note at the front gate, the driver did as I wish, and there was no funny business, such a great group of employees!

Great pizza! The crust is perfect and the toppings are unique. The best on the menu is the Mac and cheese pizza. Sounds a bit odd but it is definitely worth trying. Make sure to order ahead as their orders fill up quickly. Always ready on time!

The pizza is great but don’t bother ordering dipping sauces, they’re never included with your delivery.

This was absolutely divine, the 'Big Rick' was like a spontaneous explosion of deep and rich tones, with a meaty tornado. Capturing the magnificent pop of fresh vegetables and tasty sauce.Then we were faced with a new challenger 'Purple Haze' that has curious strokes of sweet and tangy feta with tomato. Purple onins flying in with a colorful addition to the party and to finish it off, spinach coming in with a light crispy coating on it..

Based on the comments, we really wanted to love this pizzeria, but it was a miss for us. The detroit style pizza was not good.. but the Maui Waui was decent. The person who took my order was really kind and having a chat with the delivery guy was nice, but the pizza just wasn’t our favourite.

I have been getting pizza from here for a long time and they have the best pizza ever! Amazing new ideas for toppings and great pizza classics. Always comes with kind, happy, and friendly service. Thank you!

Being living in Victoria for many years and this place is hands down one of the best takeaway pizza places in town. Order online in advance and the estimated pickup is always spot on. Try the Madi Meateor.

Great pizza, enjoyed every one we ordered but really enjoyed the St Patty's Day special beef stew pizza which was a bit of a surprise. Seemed a little bit of an odd thing to put on a pizza but had to give it a try. Wish we had ordered a bigger one. The whole blend of flavours was amazing and was a croud favourite. They should have that one on the menu year round !