Mill Creek Bakery

Wonderful Italian bread. (My first review). Now I have to add great panini, doughnuts, and cakes.

Soooo good! I bought one of the pre-made turkey subs and it was delicious. The bread was super tasty, not too tough (actually quite soft) and all the toppings were fresh amd great. Also purchases the raison butter tarts; my hisband ate 3 in one sitting. He said they were the best butter tarts he's had in years! I also grabbed the San Fansisco Sourdough; it was so fresh and tasty. Will definitely be back VERY soon!

I was in yesterday, May 23, 2023, at the end of the day and the refrigerated display cases were mostly empty - I took this as a good sign. I bought 2 Bailey's cannolis, 2 turtle brownies, 2 sweet and salty bars and 2 caramel pretzel bars.We tried the cannolis first - they literally shattered when we bit into them. Looking closer, the filling had shrunk so it no longer filled the cannoli tube. Next came the sweet and salty bars - they tasted stale and on closer inspection you could see where the chocolate shell was starting to crack and separate from itself - this item was old. Not day old but more like 5 or 6 days old. I know this because this is what one of Sweet Caroline's goodies looks like after being in my refrigerator for too long! We examined the rest of our purchase and they all had cracked and separated outer shells. I tried the caramel pretzel bar and it tasted stale as well. OMG... just throw away your old product rather than charge good money for something you know is sub par!!! Very disappointed and I will definitely be spreading the word.

Great bakery! Most of the other bakeries I called required 2-7 days advanced notice for custom orders. Mill Creek Bakery was able to create a simple, minimalist cake for me in less than 24 hours! Everyone I dealt with - the person on the phone who took the order and the person in store for the pickup - was so friendly and helpful. I would go back and recommend them to anyone. The cake was delicious too!

Best sandwichesgreat location to other services.The muffins are greatJust try it all.

I bought some bread and buns, were very fresh and the price was great! Service was wonderful too

Ordered a birthday cake, customer service was excellent, the cake was incredible!! Will be back again:)

I ordered a black forest cake, it was delicious!! Service was excellent as well. I would have given 5 stars if it wasn't so tough to find and had a sign with the bakeries name on it that you can see.

We ordered 80 of the Turtle Brownies for my work. The whole overall experience was fantastic. Great customer service, and they were able to have my order ready next day. The brownies were amazing as well!