Bakery By The Bay

We’ve been meaning to stop in at Bakery By the Bay since we moved up here and today we did. We got cinnamon rolls, tarts, a blueberry lemon loaf, a cupcake and the gentleman at the counter threw in some freshly baked chocolate chip cookies for the kids. I must say everything was delicious, the cinnamon rolls were so warm and gooey, tarts were great, the cookies I barely got a bite of because the kids devoured them but the taste I got was yummy. This will definitely be our new spot for baked treats and all our friends and family will be sent over to try out the Bakery. Thank you guys, keep doing what you do. Happy 2 years.

Give this place 10 stars!!We happened upon this place on our way to the Blue Mountains resort and I am so glad we did. We picked up some cookies and the cinnamon bun which was out of this world! It was so good, we decided to pop in on our way back to Toronto to pick up more goodies for the family. They were sold out of the cinnamon bun. :( but I needn't have worried, I got a box of the butter tarts as an alternative, and, OH. MY. GOD!! I have never tasted anything like it, they were sooooo good, it caused a fight amongst adults and children.....Steve, the owner is so friendly, he made us feel very welcome (from the UK). I can't wait to be able to go back again (fingers crossed, next year!).Stayner: Baker by the Bay is an asset to your town!

The craftsmanship was absolutely beautiful it blew me away, exceptional customer service these were the best cupcakes & cookies their attention to detail is A1. It was a beautiful touch for my sister’s birthday even though it was last minute she really finessed the limited time she had and it came out so beautiful. Talk about a pro. Your team really saved the party I'm so happy we got to try the treats, It was the talk of the party. Everyone loved it, I loved it and it truly was amazing. I’m definitely going to be coming back for more tasty treats. I was so happy she loved her surprise for her birthday party, it just added a cherry on top. Definitely going to become a lifetime customer!!

Sweet tooth craving overwhelmingly satisfied!Made from scratch sweets that are delicious. Mini cinnamon rolls and Peanut butter cookies are a must!If only you guys had a shop in Toronto, but will definitely be back anytime we’re in the area!

A gem in the town of Stayner! I first visited Bakery by the Bay a few weeks ago after hearing excellent reviews. I was not disappointed; everything was delicious! Friendly customer service, great variety, and they even have lunch specials. Must try: their giant, freshly made Cinnamon Buns (opt for the skor/caramel ones if available). I even get requests from family members to deliver to Barrie.

5 Stars doesn't do it justice. Stopped in at the recommendation of another store owner nearby (to quote the enthusiastic owner, the muffins are almost more blueberry than muffin!"

Stopped on our way home from Blue Mountain and I am so happy we did! Super kind and friendly staff and delicious treats! The cinnamon buns are amazing!

The cheesecakes and cupcakes are Amazing! The owners are the friendliness people you'll ever meet and make you feel so welcome and won't judge when you get two of everything!