The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

The pizza was fresh and Crispy. The Garlic pizza was a bit on the sweet side but I still liked it because the crust". I ordered online with them during the pandemic and it was so so and over priced for what we got. I think dining at the restaurant changed my mind. The restaurant is very casual

We enjoy the donuts and fritters here and it’s a great place in the summer for patio dining as they allowed me to have my dog on my lap. I usually get their margarita pizza and have been a few times for it. The only feedback I have is the consistency - the last time I grabbed a slice the flavours didn’t pack much of a punch and the toppings and cheese didn’t reach the edges of the slice so I was only eating dough and some sauce before hitting the crust. Having said that, I’d still return for pizza and a donut :)

Alright, Frankie, pizza review time! El Presidente suggested I try this place when visiting Toronto. My boy Portnoy needs to fix his taste buds cuz his 7.4 rating needs to be bumped up way past 8 point something!This place is a real deal American style pizza parlour. The sport is a vibe, the waiters are chill AF, and the pizza is Mamma Mia delicious! Mwah!

If you are in the area, stop by.I had purchased to-go slices from here before and they ultimately satisfy the craving of a pizza.Our first time here to sit down and order fresh pizza straight out of the oven. We were pleasantly surprised that we can use our phones to order from the table, instead of having to communicate with a server. However the server is there if you are someone who prefers order and tends to the tables frequently.As for the pizza, all pies came in 18’’ format. We ordered one to split between the two of us. Personally I like smaller pies so you can try more in one sitting.We ordered a Pepperoni Mushroom pizza, that combo of toppings is one of our favourites. We waited about 15 minutes for the pie. Came out fresh. Overall, an average pizza. Dough was crispy at the bottom and the slice was a good hold. However personally for us, it was lacking any cheese pull and the mushrooms were mushy - my assumption was they’re cooked mushrooms they put on, instead of raw. The pepperoni was not as flavourful as I wanted it to be. Personally I loved the little “globs” of sauce on top.We also tried the garlic dip. If you love dried rosemary (which I think is what the dominant flavour was), you will love this dip. However if you are looking for a straight up, all garlic sauce, this is quite different so fair warning.The donuts - throughout our entire service we saw many people come in to get the donuts in the front, so we had to try one. We got the original glazed and it was phenomenal, a highlight of the meal.

So good I keep going back! Old school, to your table pizza on a platter kinda place. Sauce is delicate, basil is fresh, pepperoni is tasty. The under carriage is cooked perfect, and holds up once you do the fold. Light crust and crunchy! Coconut cream pie is a great topper off for dessert but WAIT!...THEY HAVE DONUTS TOO! Harry and Heels california donuts are definitely a must try. Apple fritter is legit, althought we opted for the powdered blueberry and cherry filled donut and it did not disappoint. Fyi, the menu is online and they're cashless, so bring a card...Celebrities photos on the wall, cozy, casual pizza joint in the city that brings you consistently great pizza. Check it out

Went here for the first time and the way the operates was new to me for a dine in restaurant. You had to order online and pay online. Not only that, you also had to tip before you even received service. Not too much of an issue but you have to have your credit card information ready to input on your phone. I saw two older ladies leave after sitting down cause they could not check the menu online and pay based on technological restraints. Surprised there isn’t an alternative way of viewing the menu or paying.On to the food. Ordered a Margarita pizza and it took a decent amount of time to arrive. Not the biggest deal but it arrive burnt on the bottom. Wasn’t going to say anything, until the server came to ask how my meal was. Kindly enough she gave us a whole new pizza but honestly for $40 dollars after tip, I would say there are better pizzas out there for a cheaper price.Gave 4 stars rating to not ruin the business reviews but my true review would be 3/5.

I saw those pizzas being served as I walked back home and well I couldn't resist, I went there for dinner two days later. Aside from the phenomenal staff who provided an exceptional service, the pizza is an absolute must have. The ingredients are fresh and definitely considered quality ingredients given the real flavour you get with every bite. The dough is just right, light and crunchy topped with tasty marinara sauce and cheese. Prices may seem steep but then again this is not fast food, this is the real deal and at 29$, the 18inch freshly made pizza is worth every penny. Unfortunately we were too full to grab a donut and by donut I mean oversized scrumptious sweeet filled donuts!