Peter's Pizza 45 Talbot St E, Aylmer, ON N5H 1H3

Peter's Pizza





194 Reviews
  • Wednesday4–10 PM
  • Thursday4 PM–12 AM
  • Friday4 PM–12 AM
  • Saturday4 PM–12 AM
  • Sunday4–10 PM
  • Monday4–10 PM
  • Tuesday4–10 PM




Peter's Pizza 45 Talbot St E, Aylmer, ON N5H 1H3




About the Business

Peter's Pizza | We are a take-out only restaurant located in the heart of Aylmer, Ontario, owned and operated by the Geraci family for 50 years.

Contacts

Call Us
+15197732055
45 Talbot St E, Aylmer, ON N5H 1H3

Hours

  • Wednesday4–10 PM
  • Thursday4 PM–12 AM
  • Friday4 PM–12 AM
  • Saturday4 PM–12 AM
  • Sunday4–10 PM
  • Monday4–10 PM
  • Tuesday4–10 PM

Features

  • Delivery
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Takeout
  • Vegetarian options
  • Dinner
  • Casual
  • Fast service
  • Quick bite
  • Late-night food




Recommended Reviews

Peter Reimer
17.10.2023
Peter's Pizza
In my opion this is the best pizza , very friendly staff. Been going here 30+ yearsExtremely satisfied
karen louis
14.10.2023
Peter's Pizza
Amazing panzerotti!! Tried the Chicken Alfredo pizza..Delicious! Very nice looking little place! Will definitely be back!!
Karen Sackrider
03.10.2023
Peter's Pizza
Good option for a quick pizza!Ingredients are fresh, would’ve liked afew more toppings. I really like their dough though. Yeasty and bready, crunchy on the bottom and soft inside!
Jared Dalton
14.08.2023
Peter's Pizza
Really enjoyed our visit to Peter's. Great pizza, great pasta, really excellent value. Had a nice chat with the owner about his family history, can tell he really invests a lot into his craft.
Jim Bender
26.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
Excellent pizza, not from a factory. Service was excellent and the owner(the son of the founder) came out to share a laugh and tell me about his experiences as a pizza master. Great job and a great place to grab a delicious pizza pie. Definitely will return there.
Jamesson Creek
24.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
What is this.... I've had frozen pizza better :( very saddened to write this review. I love old ma and pa shops. But wow like actually a hot and ready or Kirkland frozen pizza better :( Owner please reach out help me give you a 5 star maybe person who made this was first day and you had to run to store or ?
Mathew Meek
21.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
Mario is a horrible human being. He has fired people i know personally for absolutely no reason at all after 5 years of no problems and loyal service, if he doesn’t like you because you’re young etc. he’ll tell you the Tuesday special just isn’t available and the list goes on. I have lived here 15 years and i used to see if he’s still horrible ever now and again and he always still is. He doesn’t deserve your money PLEASE take it elsewhere.
Debra Brown
21.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
Ordered pizza here a month ago and asked for a total on the phone from the young woman who answered the phone. When I went to pick it up it, the owner rang it in and it was almost $12 more than I quoted but I paid and left. The food is great. Went to order again tonight and was going to order 2 med pizzas, chicken Caesar salad and garlic bread. There are 3 kids so the pizzas had 3 of the same ingredients but I wanted to add a 4th ingredient on halves (4 different ingredients on the 4 halves). The man who answered the phone said we don't do halves dear". Very rude....I'm not your dear. When I said I guess I need to cancel the order and was about to say and will try to figure things out and call back
Percy T
18.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
I'm a huge pizza fan, and I've had my fair share of local and branch chain pizzas. Now I've had Peter's Pizza at birthday parties before, but this time I went with the panzerotti. I have to say, the food was definitely unique. The dough was lightly cooked but thoroughly, the toppings were natural and had their own distinct flavors, and the dipping sauce I got was not like the same sugary marinara sauce you would get at Domino's, but a lighter, richer and less viscous blend. And, for $14, I would say it was worth the money for sure. Not to mention that Matt was welcoming and friendly. Having Peter's Pizza is personally a nice breath of fresh air after having the same old big chain pizzas for a while, and as an added bonus, you're supporting local. Come check out Peter's pizza, you either love them or hate them, but this is the best pizza in town if you're looking for authenticity.
Agent Dion Edwards
13.07.2023
Peter's Pizza
Likely the best pizza in Canada. Great owners, salt of the earth people (Mario and Matt) and amazing food. Highly recommend if you’re in the area. This isn’t just a random plug for a small business, it’s from a self proclaimed foodie that likes good products.I grew up on Peters pizza and I travel to pick it up often. Try it if you’re on the fence. You won’t be disappointed.

Add Review

Map

45 Talbot St E, Aylmer, ON N5H 1H3
Peter's Pizza