Search
Mr. Amish 516 John St N Unit 6D, Aylmer, ON N5H 2B8

Mr. Amish





57 Reviews
Cheese shop
  • ThursdayClosed
  • FridayClosed
  • Saturday8 AM–3 PM
  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • WednesdayClosed




Mr. Amish 516 John St N Unit 6D, Aylmer, ON N5H 2B8




About the Business

Mr. Amish™ |

Contacts

Website
http://www.mramish.com/
Call Us
+15198577431
Get Directions
516 John St N Unit 6D, Aylmer, ON N5H 2B8
Change or delete

Hours

  • ThursdayClosed
  • FridayClosed
  • Saturday8 AM–3 PM
  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • WednesdayClosed
Change or delete Share Save

Features

  • Delivery
  • Wheelchair-accessible parking lot
  • Debit cards
  • Credit cards
  • In-store shopping
  • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Wi-Fi
  • Transgender safe space
  • Appointment required
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Wheelchair-accessible washroom
  • Cash-only
  • Gender-neutral washroom




Recommended Reviews

Tracy Zurbrigg
20.10.2023
Mr. Amish
Amazing salami and pickles. Today we bought pies for Thanksgiving. My mouth is watering already. Really lovely owners as well.
Teri Fralick
13.10.2023
Mr. Amish
I have never experienced such care and exceptional customer service as was provided by Mike Hathaway at Mr. Amish. I recently ordered a cheese and cracker gift basket for my grandmother. Mike helped me place my order over the phone for an assortment of cheeses and meats, and even offered to make an extra trip for gluten-free crackers. He hand-delivered the basket to my grandmother in St. Thomas and she has told me the products are delicious and were gift-wrapped beautifully.Thank you so much for going above and beyond to make this gift extra special for my grandmother, Mike. I cannot wait to come by the next time I am in Ontario for some of your delicious cheese curds!I highly recommend Mr. Amish!
Colin Cook
29.09.2023
Mr. Amish
Good 1st impressions. Will know more when I eat all the delicious goodies we picked up!Thanks Mike! Meats and cheese are a hit. Just have to wait for the butter croissants to be baked.
Adam Parker
29.09.2023
Mr. Amish
Mike is always very personable and sells quality products!I have been a customer since 2018. It doesn't matter if you buy the burgers, summer sausage, chops, honey, etc. ... They are all delicious and I would and have recommended Mr. Amish to everyone!
Copenhagen Chris
03.09.2023
Mr. Amish
Bit of a mixed review - wish I could give it a 2.5! I bought what I can only describe as a log of butter, and it didn't disappoint. Finally got to use the axe my father-in-law made me buy 17 years ago! It worked on the butter log, almost too well, but still managed to get some thick slices for my toast. That butter is a 5/5 all day long. Pricey, but as someone that loves butter (you're welcome heart!), it's worth it.Next up, cheese curds. You ever have great cheese curds? The kind that feels like you're gnawing on the branch of an Indonesian rubber tree? If so, don't buy the ones from Mr Amish. The texture and taste is not what you would expect from a good curd. They were dry, and it felt like I was eating chunks of regular cheddar cheese. Maybe I got a bad batch, but all 3 bags have been the same :(. The ones from the Aylmer sales barn (on Tuesday) are the benchmark for a great local cheese curd.These get a 1/5 from me. Sorry Mr Amish!
Sarah Harms
30.08.2023
Mr. Amish
Mike is extremely friendly and definitely puts his customers experience first. He knows that my sons enjoy sausage and he'll always give them a slice
meghann rudorfer
30.08.2023
Mr. Amish
Purchased carrot muffins and smoked pickled eggs twice now and both products are delicious! My partner and I drive from London just for Mr.Amish products :)
Deb Longthorne
28.08.2023
Mr. Amish
Varied selection of fresh and frozen meats, baking, preserves etc., hand churned rolled butter that's really flavourful. Available by pre-order for curbside pickup. Wholesome real food. Great tasting. Check out their website. Great service too!
Barry Pearson
13.08.2023
Mr. Amish
The best smoked chops money can buy. Much thicker and a lot less fat than anything found in stores and even most butcher shops. Got some of his sausage to try today. They are the same price as buying any pre packaged large brand name sausage in stores. If they are as good as his smoked chops then they are definitely worth the money. He offers a lot of other products as well and is working on adding more. Be sure to check his website to see what he offers. It's always best to call ahead and make sure he has what you want in stock. During Covid 19 sales are online and curbside pick up only.
Michelle N
30.07.2023
Mr. Amish
Mike was very considerate, personable, and helpful and his service was second to none.The meat, especially the ground beef was very lean, dark, and tasty. The hand rolled butter had a great taste to it as well.I would definitely recommend Mr Amish to anyone wanting high quality non gmo, no antibiotics, no hormones, grass fed with a bit of grain finished beef, pasture raised and free range chickens, and hand rolled butter!I will be coming back at least once a month to order from Mr Amish.Thank you for all you do!Mike

Add Review

Map

516 John St N Unit 6D, Aylmer, ON N5H 2B8
Mr. Amish