Mikey's Cream Pies
117 Reviews
- Thursday11 am–6 pm
- Friday11 am–6 pm
- Saturday11 am–5 pm
- SundayClosed
- MondayClosed
- TuesdayClosed
- Wednesday11 am–6 pm
About the Business
Pies, Butter Tarts - Mikey's Cream Pies - Hamilton, Ontario | Mikey's Cream Pies. Serving fresh to order cream pies, butter tarts and cookies. Hamilton's newest and most talked about bakery
Contacts
Website
Call Us
+19055453777
775 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 3A9
Hours
- Thursday11 am–6 pm
- Friday11 am–6 pm
- Saturday11 am–5 pm
- SundayClosed
- MondayClosed
- TuesdayClosed
- Wednesday11 am–6 pm
Features
- Delivery
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
Recommended Reviews
Stephanie C
10.10.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
Wow. Had the banana split and the chocolate peanut butter. Absolutely delicious. I was raised to only accept home made desserts but these pies are absolutely decadent and delicious. What a treat! Want to try the whole menu now
Losts Founds
20.09.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
Me and the wife were here today on a random, we had mentioned we were from Niagara at starskys and a customer over heard and told us about Mikey’s Cream pies on Burton so we decided why not, damn we were satisfied. Complete welcoming service, we got the cookies and cream it was amazing and we also got cookies and butter tarts, it’s great that everything is made in house because as a person with so many allergies I’m not worried with these as they can tell me 100% doesn’t contain my specific allergen.
DSS
17.09.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
We love supporting local businesses! We pre-ordered the chocolate peanut butter pie and were not disappointed. Creamy, not too rich, with the perfect amount of crunch. Online ordering was a breeze, as was pickup and communication. Easily a 5*.
Coco Taylor
08.09.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
What gem ! Delicious treats and the owner gave my daughter a free cookie because “it’s the law”. 100% recommend Mikey’s Cream Pies to anyone looking for a sweet treat !
J Lee
28.08.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
We love the fact that they offer individual pie cups - so we can sample different ones. They have a (seasonal) strawberry one that is our go to. Next time we go, we'll be trying their soups. Love this little gem on Barton Street!
Don Chrysler
27.07.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
Picked up a banana cream pie. Cut first piece, and it was all runny. The whole pie was not set and runny. Maybe their other pies are better. But I won't buy another banana creme pie from their again. Mostly whip creme and little filling.
Stan Hosdar
22.07.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
Oh my god. These pies are soo good. Peanut butter is dreamy. I have never had anything like this.Its like cheesecake.... it's so delicious and unique. I will be back for more!
Meagan W
20.07.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
This is our first time ordering cream pies from Mikey’s and we are blown away to say the least. We got banana, coconut and chocolate cream pies as pictured. We got the 6” inch pies so we could try a few and so happy we did. They are so flavourful with each new bite. This is definitely going to be our regular place for desserts now!
billc1664
18.07.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
Absolutely fantastic! Picked up a coconut cream pie for a friends birthday. Best we’ve ever had by far. Would highly recommend!
Amanda Blazek
17.07.2023
Mikey's Cream Pies
It was my first time ordering from Mike's cream pies. I ordered the peanut butter cream pie. So delicious and what a treat as I just finished the school year. Was nice to celebrate with this delicious treat.
Add Review
Map
775 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 3A9
Mikey's Cream Pies