The Little Pie Shack

Cute bakery in town. Employees were super nice. We got 6 tarts for $24. The butter tart and strawberry tart tasted great but the crumble tarts tasted freezer burnt. I tried to reheat them to see if it would taste different but unfortunately we had to throw them away. I was curious so I read through some of the previous reviews and saw that some people experienced the same.

Bought a strawberry rhubarb pie yesterday. Got home and was disappointed to find there to be no strawberries in my pie. Only rhubarb, it was extremely tart. Not what i was expecting. The crust was good though.

Nice little bake shop. Lots of treats. A bit pricy for a baked good, in my opinion, but tasty. We especially enjoyed the carrot cake. And it’s in a nice little town.

Stopped here driving through Fenton Falls. A lovely little spot, we chose (clockwise from top left) a butter tart with raisins, date square, brownie, peanut butter brownie, Nanaimo bar and a date square. All were delicious! A nice spot to stop, had Kawartha Dairy ice cream too — not something we choose to have in November.

Such a cute little shop, and the ladies are super friendly and helpful. We will definitely come back!

I purchased a expensive strawberry rhubarb pie($25.00) from this bakery and when I cut into it it was like soup. I went back to the bakery today and showed them the pictures and was told, all their pies are like that. Personally I like my pie with substance. This will be the last time I purchase anything from this bakery.

Had a fabulous tuna wrap!It was my first visit (but not my last) and I had the pleasure to meet the owner Joann.What a hidden gem in the great little town of Fenelon Falls!

I took my family on a “Guess Where Trip” called butter tart trail. The Little Pie Shack was our second stop of the day. Since we were on a butter tart tour I ordered six butter tarts. Two plain..two pecan and two raisin. Since we were in the PIE shack we also bought an apple pie. Our son had two scoops of ice cream.I was so excited to try the butter tarts that when we got back to the car I had to have one. The only issue was they were so fresh that the fill didn’t set up yet. I made a mess but it was worth it delicious.When we got home later in the day I tried a second one and it didn’t disappoint. We’ll try the pie after dinner.We’re from Brampton so I can’t drive up every weekend but I’ll be back for sure.