Hartley's Tavern
330 Reviews
$$
- Thursday4–8 PM
- Friday4–8 PM
- Saturday4–8 PM
- SundayClosed
- MondayClosed
- TuesdayClosed
- WednesdayClosed
About the Business
Hartleys Tavern | Picton | Prince Edward County Restaurants | Hartleys Tavern is a unique downtown wine and craft beer bar offers an elegant, relaxed, and casual atmosphere with a unique creative menu.
Contacts
Website
Call Us
+16134768888
19 Elizabeth St, Picton, ON K0K 2T0
Hours
- Thursday4–8 PM
- Friday4–8 PM
- Saturday4–8 PM
- SundayClosed
- MondayClosed
- TuesdayClosed
- WednesdayClosed
Features
- Delivery
- Wheelchair-accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
- Wi-Fi
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible washroom
- Healthy options
- Small plates
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Washroom
- Casual
- Cozy
- Groups
- Accepts reservations
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Hard liquor
- Wine
- Bar on-site
- High chairs
- Late-night food
- Romantic
- Upscale
- Great cocktails
- Gender-neutral washroom
Recommended Reviews
Laurel Price-Jones
08.10.2023
Hartley's Tavern
We went as 6 people to celebrate a family birthday. The service was excellent. It was a busy restaurant, but we never felt rushed. The noise level was perfect. We could all hear our conversations at our table.We had the 3 course dinner option with a few substitutions. The meals were all delicious with beautiful presentation. There are fancy cocktails and mocktails and a fairly extensive moderately priced wine list. We had the full selection of desserts between the 6 of us. The blue cheese ice cream sounded unusual for sure, but paired with the fresh figs and walnut cakes, it was really unique and tasty. All of the starters, meals and desserts were excellent and we were all very full and satisfied!!I highly recommended and will be happy to return!!
Tom Grana
05.10.2023
Hartley's Tavern
This is easily *the best* restaurant in the County.The chef - who is incredibly young - is a friggin genius. They keep some standing items on the menu (e.g. hanger steak), but he plays with variations on them which are fantastic. A few years ago, the steak was done in a chocolate mole sauce which was unbelievable. This season, he's doing it marinated in a Roja sauce, and honestly they might both be in the top 5 steaks I've had in my life.Almost everything here is amazing - whether simple and satisfying (like the tomato capellini) or insanely indulgent, like the brown butter lobster roll they are currently serving.The place is classy without being stuffy, amazing quality and not overpriced. I know this review may sound like I'm connected to the restaurant, but it really is just that good.Lastly, so many restaurants pull off good appetizers and mains, but fall short in the desserts. I just had a walnut Financier with a blue cheese ice cream and candied figs which was good enough for my last meal on Earth.Cannot recommend this place enough.
Emmet Donnelly
28.09.2023
Hartley's Tavern
Very professional, friendly service. Couldn't fault the food, all the ingredients tasted so fresh. You can see a lot of care and attention is put into the dishes here
jm
04.09.2023
Hartley's Tavern
ABSOLUTELY MUST TRY RESTAURANT IF YOU ARE IN THE AREA! Don't be turned off by the name... this is definitely not a tavern, more like a very high end French bistro. The chef owner is absolutely obsessively passionate about the creation of each dish and it's execution. Each dish is a flabbergasting experience. When receiving a new wave of dishes we said wow I don't know how many times. We're from Montreal and we had dinners at amazing restaurants all over Canada and Europe and this one ranks right up there with the best. At $64 for the three course meal it is simply a steal. We highly recommend the bison tartare, the souffle, the venison and the hanger steak (ranks way up there as one of the best steaks I ever had). We actually loved this place so much that we canceled our reservation in another restaurant to eat there again on our two day stay in Picton. Service is also very attentive, supremely professional without being intrusive. My only recommendation to the chef owner is to change the restaurant name to Hartley's Bistro as I suspect that potential clients may simply pass when they read tavern" without taking the time to read the reviews."
Joe Smith
03.09.2023
Hartley's Tavern
My partner and I both had the 3 course dinner and shared 6 different plates.Everything on the plate was there for a reason. Beautiful presentation, exquisite taste, perfectly cooked.
Ray
31.08.2023
Hartley's Tavern
We visited Picton in early August 2022. We ate dinner on the patio at Hartleys Tavern.The service was exceptional and the staff was very knowledgeable.I had the seared duck breast and it came with a Kimchi pancake which was exceptional!!! We will definitely eat here again and I would highly recommend!!
Christian Jaehn-Kreibaum
28.08.2023
Hartley's Tavern
FANTASTIC DINING at Hartley's. Three of us went last night and we enjoyed a variety of appetizers, main courses and dessert. The sparkling wine, white & red wine were all tasty. The sparkling wine could have been colder and sometimes it was hard to understand our server. More because of the mask and the restaurant was quite loud." Every guest seemed to enjoy themselves. We will be back regardless. It was our third time."
April Pleasants
12.08.2023
Hartley's Tavern
If you want to get excellent service, ambiance and great food, Hartely's Tavern is a place to go. We went here with friends and surprisingly their food is comparable to some high-end restaurants in downtown Toronto. I had fish with curry sauce on a bed of sticky rice and vegetables on the side. Their appetizers are amazing particularly the Yorkshire pudding with shredded lamb. For desserts, the cheesecake with coconut and berry was delicious!
Richard
19.07.2023
Hartley's Tavern
My wife made reservations at Hartley’s for my 65th birthday as she knows it is my favourite eating establishment in Picton. The food is delicious and presented well. Shelby’s infectious smile and personality are always a great way to start the evening! Our server Blaine was well dressed & attentive outlining the changes to the menu-always something new & tasty prepared by Jarod the amazing chef! Janine the owner always comes by with a pleasant smile & asks about your meal.The entire staff are part of a successful team that compliments each other & positively promotes Hartley’s restaurant. I highly recommend Hartley’s in PEC.
Add Review
Map
19 Elizabeth St, Picton, ON K0K 2T0
Hartley's Tavern